Homes for Sale in Port McNicoll
14 active · residential · updated daily
Browse 14 homes for sale across Port McNicoll, Ontario. Asking prices currently range from $140K to $1.75M, with a median around $642,450. Every listing below links straight to its full home details, photos, and map location.
Listings refresh daily, so check back as new home inventory comes to market.
Market Snapshot14 homes
- Active homes
- 14
- Median price
- $642,450
- Average price
- $810,088
- Price range
- $140K – $1.75M
Sold data
Homes in Port McNicoll — recent sold market
Homes in Port McNicoll took a median of 22 days to sell over the last 365 days, with the quickest quarter selling within 13 days and the slowest quarter taking more than 39, across 40 recorded sales.
That clock counts only the listing each home finally sold on. Measured from the first time these properties came to market, including any earlier listings that were withdrawn and re-entered, the median is 42 days.
The median sale price was $499,900.
Homes sold for about 2.8% below asking on average, so there was room to negotiate.
About 18% of sales closed above the list price.
Around 12% of sellers reduced their price before finding a buyer.
- Median days to sell
- 22
- Median sale price
- $499,900
- Sale-to-list ratio
- 97.2%
- Sold above asking
- 18%
Based on 40 recorded sales in the last 1 year — a small sample, so treat these figures as indicative. Aggregate statistics only; individual sale prices are not shown.
On the market
Homes for Sale in Port McNicoll
$499,000
Detached222,000–2,500 sqft247 POPLAR AVENUE, Port McNicoll, Tay
$549,900
Detached4+12700–1,100 sqft379 WARDELL STREET, Port McNicoll, Tay
$269,950
Detached00700–1,100 sqft250 KINGFISHER AVENUE, Port McNicoll, Tay
$634,999
Detached5+221,100–1,500 sqft363 WARDELL STREET, Port McNicoll, Tay
$549,990
Detached5+221,100–1,500 sqft461 BARNES AVENUE, Port McNicoll, Tay
$899,900
Detached321,100–1,500 sqft58 METHODIST ISLAND, Port McNicoll, Tay
$1,499,900
Detached5+231,500–2,000 sqft93 SILVER BIRCH CRESCENT, Port McNicoll, Tay
$699,000
Detached331,100–1,500 sqft753 FIFTH AVENUE, Port McNicoll, Tay
$1,699,900
Detached332,000–2,500 sqft7 DOCK LANE, Port McNicoll, Tay
$999,000
Detached332,000–2,500 sqft740 MIDLAND AVENUE, Port McNicoll, Tay
$139,900
Detached31700–1,100 sqft366 TALBOT STREET, Port McNicoll, Tay
$649,900
Detached322,000–2,500 sqft3 EARLDOM BOULEVARD, Port McNicoll, Tay
$1,749,900
Detached432,500–3,000 sqft18 SWAN LANE, Port McNicoll, Tay
$499,998
Detached6+231,100–1,500 sqft856 NEY AVENUE, Port McNicoll, Tay
Nearby
Homes for sale nearby
Explore more
More in Port McNicoll
Good to know
Frequently asked questions
How many homes are for sale in Port McNicoll?
There are 14 homes for sale in Port McNicoll, Ontario as of today. The list updates daily from current MLS® data.
What is the typical price of homes for sale in Port McNicoll?
The median asking price for homes for sale in Port McNicoll is approximately $642,450. Prices range from $140K to $1.75M. Individual prices vary with size, condition, and neighbourhood.
What is the average price of homes for sale in Port McNicoll?
The average asking price is $810,088, while the median is $642,450. When the average is higher, it indicates a cluster of premium home listings pulling the mean upward. The median is usually the better benchmark for a typical buyer.
How often are homes listings in Port McNicoll updated?
Listings are refreshed every day from live MLS® feeds, so counts and prices on this page reflect what is currently on the market in Port McNicoll. New listings are added and sold properties are removed within 24 hours.
What is the estimated mortgage payment for homes in Port McNicoll?
Based on the median price of $642,450, a 20% down payment of $128K leaves a principal of about $514K. At a 5% rate over 25 years, that works out to roughly $3,005/month before property tax and condo fees. Use our mortgage calculator for a personalised estimate.
Show 2 more questionsShow fewer questions
How do I find the right home for sale in Port McNicoll?
Use the AI chat on PropertySearchGPT to describe what you need in plain English — budget, bedrooms, neighbourhood — and get an instant shortlist. You can also filter by price, property type, and distance on the interactive map. Every listing links to full details, photos, and recent comparable sales.
Can I get notified when a new home is listed for sale in Port McNicoll?
Yes — create a free account and set a saved search for homes for sale in Port McNicoll. PropertySearchGPT will send you an alert as soon as a matching home hits the MLS®, so you never miss a new listing.
Get alerts for homes for sale in Port McNicoll
Be first to know when a matching listing hits the market. Set up instant alerts and analyze any property's numbers in seconds.