$3,649,900
For sale: Detached

Set on a rare half-acre backing onto protected conservation land, 57 Victoria Street offers a level of privacy and calm rarely found within town limits. Surrounded by mature trees and curated gardens, the home feels intentionally removed, with each window framing a quiet connection to the outdoors. It's a setting that offers true serenity without isolation. Known as The Judges House, this is one of Milton's most iconic addresses, reimagined through a complete two-year, $2 million transformation that merges its Victorian architecture with an uncompromising standard of modern living. With over 5,000 sq ft, the home is designed for both presence and ease. A more traditional front layout transitions into an open rear living space, creating a natural balance between structure and flow. Light moves effortlessly throughout, enhanced by expansive windows, refined millwork, and thoughtfully integrated living spaces. Every finish, fixture, and system has been specified without compromise - a home that performs as beautifully as it looks. A fully detached two-storey coach house is a self-contained residence that introduces rare flexibility, ideal for a private workspace, studio, or guest residence, set apart from the main home. While the setting feels calm and removed, seamless access to the city and a short walk to Main Street create a true sense of escape without compromise or isolation. A rare offering defined by privacy, scale, and architectural significance.
Sold data
Detached homes in Milton (OM Old Milton) took a median of 20 days to sell over the last 90 days, with the quickest quarter selling within 11 days and the slowest quarter taking more than 43, across 181 recorded sales.
That clock counts only the listing each home finally sold on. Measured from the first time these properties came to market, including any earlier listings that were withdrawn and re-entered, the median is 49 days.
The median sale price was $1,149,000.
Homes sold for about 2.5% below asking on average, so there was room to negotiate.
About 15% of sales closed above the list price.
Around 22% of sellers reduced their price before finding a buyer.
Based on 181 recorded sales in the last 90 days. Aggregate statistics only; individual sale prices are not shown.
Schools
Milton (OM Old Milton) has 30 Fraser Institute–rated schools (24 elementary and 6 secondary), averaging 6.9/10.
School ratings from the Fraser Institute's Ontario school report cards.
Currently for sale

$3,799,000
Detached127 ELGIN MILLS ROAD W, Mill Pond, Richmond Hill

$3,899,000
Detached35 DAYMOND DRIVE, Rural Puslinch East, Puslinch

$3,999,999
Detached6 SUGARBUSH COURT, 1049 - Rural Halton Hills, Halton Hills

$3,899,999
Detached2 EDGEFOREST DRIVE, Toronto Gore Rural Estate, Brampton

$3,828,000
Detached42 SOMERVILLE STREET, Stouffville, Whitchurch-Stouffville

$3,199,999
Detached477 SAVOLINE BOULEVARD, 1036 - SC Scott, Milton

$3,999,900
Detached6195 MILBUROUGH LINE, Rural Burlington, Burlington

$4,288,888
Detached24 MCARTHUR HEIGHTS, Snelgrove, Brampton