$1,250,000
For sale: Detached

Welcome to the historic Bethel Presbyterian Church at Price's Corners in East Garafraxa, a truly one-of-a-kind residence rich in character and heritage (circa 1892). This converted church offers a rare blend of architectural charm and modern comfort, featuring a grand sanctuary-style living space with soaring ceilings, a striking fireplace, and expansive areas designed for both relaxation and entertaining.Set on a picturesque countryside property, the home provides a serene and private setting surrounded by natural beauty. Outdoor amenities include a pool and hot tub creating a spa-like retreat, multiple seating areas, and a fire pit ideal for year-round enjoyment. Interior spaces are thoughtfully designed to balance open-concept living with quiet areas for reflection, work, or leisure.Conveniently located within close proximity to Orangeville, Fergus, Elora, Erin, Caledon, and Hockley Valley, the property offers easy access to local shops, dining, and everyday amenities while maintaining a peaceful rural atmosphere. Nearby conservation areas and provincial parks, including Hockley Valley, Mono Cliffs, Forks of the Credit, and Belwood Lake, provide endless opportunities for outdoor recreation.Significant updates since 2018 include mechanical and system improvements such as the water pump, Pellet Wood Burning Stoves, furnace, and heat pump, along with exterior upgrades including fascia and eavestroughs, enhancing both efficiency and long-term value.A landmark property with over 130 years of history, this exceptional home presents a rare opportunity to own a distinctive piece of Dufferin County's heritage-perfect for those seeking a unique lifestyle property with character, space, and modern amenities.
Sold data
Detached homes in East Garafraxa took a median of 45 days to sell over the last 730 days, with the quickest quarter selling within 19 days and the slowest quarter taking more than 64, across 34 recorded sales.
That clock counts only the listing each home finally sold on. Measured from the first time these properties came to market, including any earlier listings that were withdrawn and re-entered, the median is 86 days.
The median sale price was $1,422,000.
Homes sold for about 3.0% below asking on average, so there was room to negotiate.
About 6% of sales closed above the list price.
Around 15% of sellers reduced their price before finding a buyer.
Based on 34 recorded sales in the last 2 years — a small sample, so treat these figures as indicative. Aggregate statistics only; individual sale prices are not shown.
Currently for sale

$1,279,000
Detached244337 5 SIDE ROAD, Rural Amaranth, Amaranth

$1,400,000
Detached16 CHARLES COOPER COURT, Kleinburg, Vaughan

$999,000
Detached343071 FIFTEENTH SIDE ROAD, Rural Amaranth, Amaranth

$1,499,000
Detached19976 KENNEDY ROAD, Rural Caledon, Caledon

$1,350,000
Detached518644 COUNTY 124 ROAD, Rural Melancthon, Melancthon

$1,249,999
Detached32 WILLOUGHBY WAY, Georgetown, Halton Hills

$1,040,000
Detached52 AUTUMN DRIVE, Caledon Village, Caledon

$1,349,000
Detached24 CACHET HILL CRESCENT, Sonoma Heights, Vaughan