$739,900
For sale: Detached

What if you stopped compromising on space just to stay closer to the GTA? Welcome to 877 O'Reilly Crescent-2,534 sq. ft. above grade, a seriously great layout and the kind of value that makes Shelburne worth the drive. Impeccably maintained by owners with next-level pride of ownership, this one shows it. Modern upgraded exterior, hardwood floors throughout, new fireplace (2023), new windows, exterior doors and garage door (2023-2024), plus rooms that are actually big enough to live in. A proper dining room fits the big table AND the hutch. The huge family room has a gas fireplace. The oversized eat-in kitchen features upgraded stainless steel appliances, under-cabinet lighting, and there's a separate main-floor office for the WFH crowd-or turn it into a den, playroom or living room. Upstairs? THREE full bathrooms-a huge win for big, blended or multi-generational families and anyone who's over the morning bathroom battle. Outside, there's a massive concrete driveway with parking for 4 PLUS a double garage that's insulated, programmable permanent exterior lighting (no climbing to put up lights), a spacious yard, concrete patio and shed. Add a generator, OWNED tankless hot water system and a huge untouched basement with bathroom rough-in and cold cellar, ready for whatever comes next-gym, theatre, games room, extra bedrooms or all of the above. And Shelburne? It's the small-town alternative to GTA pricing without giving up the essentials. Families have access to JK-8 options including Centennial Hylands, Glenbrook and Hyland Heights, French Immersion at Centennial Hylands, Centre Dufferin District High School, plus Catholic options including St. Benedict CES and Robert F. Hall CSS. More house. More driveway. More bathrooms. More breathing room. Less GTA-sized mortgage. That's the trade-up.
Sold data
Detached homes in Shelburne took a median of 34 days to sell over the last 365 days, with the quickest quarter selling within 17 days and the slowest quarter taking more than 56, across 92 recorded sales.
That clock counts only the listing each home finally sold on. Measured from the first time these properties came to market, including any earlier listings that were withdrawn and re-entered, the median is 88 days.
The median sale price was $699,999.
Homes sold for about 2.4% below asking on average, so there was room to negotiate.
About 8% of sales closed above the list price.
Around 22% of sellers reduced their price before finding a buyer.
Based on 92 recorded sales in the last 1 year — a small sample, so treat these figures as indicative. Aggregate statistics only; individual sale prices are not shown.
Schools
Shelburne has 4 Fraser Institute–rated schools (3 elementary and 1 secondary), averaging 4.0/10.
School ratings from the Fraser Institute's Ontario school report cards.
Currently for sale

$749,000
Detached269 DINGMAN STREET, Arthur, Wellington North

$799,000
Detached734 ANISHINAABE DRIVE, Shelburne, Shelburne

$769,000
Detached69 SEASON CRESCENT, Wasaga Beach, Wasaga Beach

$895,000
Detached124 WALKER BOULEVARD, Alliston, New Tecumseth

$770,000
Detached224 MURIEL STREET, Shelburne, Shelburne

$959,900
Detached113 STRACHAN TRAIL, Beeton, New Tecumseth

$749,999
Detached38 BLACK WILLOW DRIVE, Holly, Barrie

$949,999
Detached75 TREETOPS BOULEVARD, Rural New Tecumseth, New Tecumseth