171 KILLALY STREET W, Port Colborne (Main Street)

$589,988

For sale: Detached

Detached at 171 KILLALY STREET W, Port Colborne (Main Street)
Property type
Detached
Bedrooms / bathrooms
7 bedrooms, 4 bathrooms
Living area
3,000 sqft
MLS®
MLS® X13736342
Neighbourhood
877 - Main Street

A true Port Colborne landmark, 171 Killaly Street West has stood as a cornerstone of the community since 1863. This magnificent triple-brick, Heritage-designated home offers over 3,100 sq. ft. of living space, soaring 10.5 ft ceilings, and the kind of irreplaceable character that simply cannot be replicated today. Offering exceptional flexibility, this property presents the opportunity for a multi-unit home and is ideal for multigenerational living, large families, or those seeking potential rental income. Inside, you'll find 7 bedrooms and 3.5 bathrooms, along with a spacious kitchen, formal dining room, main floor family room, laundry, and a 4-season sunroom that brings in beautiful natural light and year-round comfort. Outside, the property continues to impress with a detached 30x24 garage featuring radiant heat and hydro, offering excellent potential for additional living space, workshop, or studio use. A separate carriage house addition further expands the possibilities, complete with its own living space, loft, and private fenced outdoor area-ideal for extended family, guests. Two driveways, a large rear deck, and generous outdoor space further enhance the property's overall function and usability. With updated electrical, and plumbing throughout, this historic residence blends timeless character with modern upgrades. Perfectly positioned in a family-friendly location directly across from McKay Elementary School and within walking distance to Port Colborne High School, this property also offers easy access to parks, the Welland Canal waterfront, local restaurants, boutique shopping, and all the charm that downtown Port Colborne has to offer. This is a rare opportunity to own one of Port Colborne's most iconic addresses.

Sold data

Detached homes in Port Colborne (Main Street) — recent sold market

Detached homes in Port Colborne (Main Street) took a median of 27 days to sell over the last 90 days, with the quickest quarter selling within 13 days and the slowest quarter taking more than 61, across 62 recorded sales.

That clock counts only the listing each home finally sold on. Measured from the first time these properties came to market, including any earlier listings that were withdrawn and re-entered, the median is 48 days.

The median sale price was $499,900.

Homes sold for about 3.8% below asking on average, so there was room to negotiate.

About 8% of sales closed above the list price.

Around 23% of sellers reduced their price before finding a buyer.

Median days to sell
27
Median sale price
$499,900
Sale-to-list ratio
96.2%
Sold above asking
8%

Based on 62 recorded sales in the last 90 days — a small sample, so treat these figures as indicative. Aggregate statistics only; individual sale prices are not shown.

Schools

Schools in Port Colborne (Main Street)

Port Colborne (Main Street) has 10 Fraser Institute–rated schools (8 elementary and 2 secondary), averaging 6.8/10.

Rated schools
10
Elementary
8
Secondary
2
Average rating
6.8 / 10

Top-rated schools in Port Colborne (Main Street)

  • Steele Street — elementary, Port ColborneFraser rating 9.5/10
  • Oakwood — elementary, Port ColborneFraser rating 8.8/10
  • McKay — elementary, Port ColborneFraser rating 7.4/10
  • St Patrick Catholic — elementary, Port ColborneFraser rating 7.3/10
  • DeWitt Carter — elementary, Port ColborneFraser rating 7.1/10
  • Port Colborne — secondary, Port ColborneFraser rating 6.5/10

School ratings from the Fraser Institute's Ontario school report cards.

Currently for sale

Homes for sale near 171 KILLALY STREET W