209 BAY STREET, Oro-Medonte (Shanty Bay)

$4,490,000

For sale: Detached

Detached at 209 BAY STREET, Oro-Medonte (Shanty Bay)
Property type
Detached
Bedrooms / bathrooms
5 bedrooms, 5 bathrooms
Living area
3,500 sqft
MLS®
MLS® S13508726
Neighbourhood
Shanty Bay

Rare Waterfront Estate in Prestigious Shanty BayA rare opportunity to own an exceptional waterfront retreat in the heart of Shanty Bay. Tucked away on a quiet dead-end street, this remarkable property offers nearly 200 feet of pristine, south-facing shoreline on Kempenfelt Bay, with crystal-clear deep water ideal for swimming, boating, and enjoying breathtaking panoramic views.Set on a private, beautifully treed lot, the estate includes a main cottage, guest house, and bunkie above the garage, providing a total of 12 bedrooms, 8 bathrooms, and 3 kitchens. With ample space for extended family, guests, or potential rental income, this property offers outstanding versatility.Most principal rooms capture stunning lake views, while the outdoor spaces are designed to embrace waterfront living. Features include a lakeside concrete patio, marine railway with covered boat slip, and a spacious rooftop deck above the boathouse-perfect for entertaining and enjoying spectacular sunsets.The main cottage is filled with warmth and character, featuring hardwood floors, a stone fireplace, a charming Muskoka room overlooking the water, and a cozy third-level loft retreat.Additional highlights include a heated garage with bunkie accommodation above, parking for 10+ vehicles, and a secluded, park-like setting surrounded by mature trees for exceptional privacy.Conveniently located just 10 minutes from Barrie, Royal Victoria Regional Health Centre, shopping, dining, and everyday amenities, and approximately one hour from Toronto. Enjoy easy boat access to Friday Harbour Resort and nearby recreational trails.Whether enjoyed as a private family compound, multi-generational getaway, or investment opportunity with future severance or redevelopment potential, this is a rare chance to own a legacy waterfront property in one of Lake Simcoe's most coveted communities.

Sold data

Detached homes in Oro-Medonte (Shanty Bay) — recent sold market

Detached homes in Oro-Medonte (Shanty Bay) took a median of 26 days to sell over the last 90 days, with the quickest quarter selling within 11 days and the slowest quarter taking more than 51, across 76 recorded sales.

That clock counts only the listing each home finally sold on. Measured from the first time these properties came to market, including any earlier listings that were withdrawn and re-entered, the median is 52 days.

The median sale price was $947,450.

Homes sold for about 3.7% below asking on average, so there was room to negotiate.

About 11% of sales closed above the list price.

Around 21% of sellers reduced their price before finding a buyer.

Median days to sell
26
Median sale price
$947,450
Sale-to-list ratio
96.3%
Sold above asking
11%

Based on 76 recorded sales in the last 90 days — a small sample, so treat these figures as indicative. Aggregate statistics only; individual sale prices are not shown.

Schools

Schools in Oro-Medonte (Shanty Bay)

Oro-Medonte (Shanty Bay) has 1 Fraser Institute–rated school (1 elementary).

Rated schools
1
Elementary
1

Top-rated schools in Oro-Medonte (Shanty Bay)

  • Guthrie — elementary, Oro-MedonteFraser rating 7.2/10

School ratings from the Fraser Institute's Ontario school report cards.

Currently for sale

Homes for sale near 209 BAY STREET